Thoughts on the Death Penalty...
I am largely against the death penalty not out of any particular moral qualm surrounding killing an individual (though I do have them and do believe such arguments to be among the most persuasive). I am against the death penalty because more and more people are being released and acquitted of the crimes that they had originally been convicted for. This false conviction rate also occurs in death penalty cases and my feeling is so long as there is any possibility of an innocent person being convicted and executed then it is not appropriate for the penalty to be enforced. The life of one innocent person is more valuable then the lives of any number of murderers.
I know... I know... I just
finished saying over on another blog that the idea that all human life is sacred and precious has a great deal of resonance for me but I also said that I’m not perfect and have a hard time living up to that ideal.
In my opinion... here’s a list of people who should not be pro-death penalty:
1. Anyone who believes abortion is wrong because it is murder. It is hypocritical to take the stance that murder is wrong and then not uphold that stance in every instance. If you believe life begins at conception and abortion is murder, you should also believe that the death penalty is wrong. If you don’t then it calls into question your conviction on your first stance.
2. Any catholic who accepts the doctrine undertaken by the Holy See to protect pedophile priests. If you believe that confession and absolution entitle a person to protection from the actions in their past then you must apply that belief to those under sentence of the death penalty as well. If the pedophile priest is protected because firing them and handing them over to the authorities violates the sanctity of confession and removes the possibility of contrition and redemption, the application of the death penalty does so in even greater measure.
3. Anyone who considers themselves a pacifist and believes that omission and commission are two sides of the same coin when it comes to taking action.
4. Anyone who feels moral outrage over the ordered stoning deaths of the women who have been sentenced to die in Nigeria for giving birth outside of wedlock. It is the punishment for the crime that they have committed.
I was scared during the sniper’s reign of terror. Two of the killings took place in my home county but I still think that it is appalling that the decision of where these individuals were going to stand trial was based primarily on the potential for both of them to receive the death penalty. That is not the ‘innocent until proven guilty’ ideal that is supposed to be the hallmark of our justice system.
if you are deciding where they are going to be killed, you have already decided their guilt. And that is a scary thought regardless. The primary concern should be “can they get a fair trial” not “can we kill the 17 year old in this county”.
just my thoughts...