No Womb to Argue...
Meryl Yourish has been unsuccessfully trying to unembroil herself from a discussion on reproductive rights. Now, I admit that I fall pretty heavily on the "women's bodies, women's choice" side of the argument with the single caveat that I do not believe abortion should ever become just another form of birth control. I do believe that part of a woman taking control of her body is taking control of it before sex and that means saying no when the prospect of unprotected sex looms.
I've been staying out of the argument till this point feeling that both sides were being pretty well represented with its centrists and fringes. Enter Tony at
'The Rant Factory' who said something that finally managed to push my buttons significantly enough to drop me off the fence.
First off, I'd like to point out that, with 3 kids of my own, I've got "street cred" on this topic. We (my wife and I) went through natural births all three times, and over the course of 6 years have probably put enough study hours into childbirth to get an Associate's Degree in it. I'm sure my wife would agree that anyone who goes through 3 natural births should get a diploma, but that's another topic altogether. Oh, and for those of you who raised an eyebrow at me using the word "we" to describe childbirth: the "we" part is why I've got street cred.
Well... I hate to be the bearer of bad news but if this is what you are carrying as "street cred" then I'm afraid you sir are poor indeed. You do not have experience with childbirth. What you have is experience WATCHING childbirth happen. Maybe holding your wife’s hand, being comforting, sharing the same room, helping her “breathe” by going hee-hee-hoo, hee-hee-hoo. Fetching ice chips, mopping brows. Or anything else you may or may not have done. In essence
seeing childbirth happen. In all of its glory (and gory). You may have been the most comforting supportive person on the planet but until you actually push a baby down the birthing canal and out into the world you have zero experience with actual childbirth. And you are in no position to make judgements on how stressful (physically and especially emotionally) such a process may or may not be.
Your wife… yes. You? No. And even if your wife agrees with your assessment 100%... here's the wonderful thing about individuals. They differ.
It is a wonderful touchy-feely delusion that we (men) allow ourselves to believe. That we shared the experience of childbirth. I will never forget being in the room when our daughter was born. I am certain my hand still bears the marks of the pen that my wife inadvertantly jabbed into the flesh of my palm. (at least I tell myself it was inadvertant... it helps me sleep at night) It was amazing and frantic and scary and every emotion I have ever experienced all experienced at once.
But here's the thing.... she could have had that baby without me. I added to her experience and I came away with experiences all my own. None of which had anything to do with me giving birth.
So save the street credit and stick with your opinion. There are some authorities that we cannot claim no matter how much we try.
Side note having nothing to do with the above: I wonder if the religious right that has taken up this call for "father's rights" would be as supportive if the woman wanted to have the baby and the father wanted to force her to have an abortion.